Case Details

Year Initiated/Committed


Year Resolved


Settlement Amount

$25,000 civil penalty


Winona County District Court, Minnesota

Docket Number


Lead State


Participating States



Tim Amdahl Chevrolet Co., Nystrom Motors, Sugar Loaf Ford Lincoln, Mercury, Walz Buick Oldsmobile GMC

Case Description

Plaintiff State alleged a scheme by which automobile body repair shops in the Winona, Minnesota, area could effectively eliminate competition for their services by agreeing to provide two repair estimates to customers. They did so by a practice of exchanging blank estimate pads with each other, and allowing each other to write or obtain false ‘courtesy’ estimates (quoting a higher price) on their competitors’ estimate
forms, the complaint alleged. According to the complaints, the defendants were able
to decrease price competition among themselves, and control and maintain the market price of auto body repair work at higher than normal levels.